How to make
The oven is preheated to 200°C / 400°F. A baking tray is lined with parchment paper, or four separate parchment parcels are prepared if each herring will be baked individually. This method keeps the fish moist and lets the lemon, onion and rosemary perfume the flesh while it cooks.
The cleaned whole herring is rinsed briefly under cold water and patted very dry with kitchen paper. Drying the fish helps the olive oil and seasoning cling better and gives the skin a more appetizing roasted finish. Each fish is lightly scored on both sides with shallow diagonal cuts, without cutting too deep into the flesh.
The onions are sliced into thin half-moons. The carrot is grated or cut into very fine strips. The lemon is sliced into thin rounds, with a few extra wedges kept aside for serving.
The vegetables are tossed with half of the olive oil, a pinch of salt, a little black pepper and the sweet paprika.
A bed of onion and carrot is spread in the center of each parchment sheet. One whole herring is placed on top. A few lemon slices and a small rosemary sprig are tucked inside the cavity of each fish, then the remaining lemon and rosemary are arranged over the top. The fish is drizzled with the rest of the olive oil and seasoned with the remaining salt and pepper.
The parchment is folded around the fish to form loose but well-closed parcels, so the steam stays inside during baking. The parcels are placed on the tray and baked for 20 to 25 minutes. The exact time depends on the size of the herring; the fish is ready when the flesh flakes easily near the backbone and looks opaque throughout.
For a slightly more roasted finish, the parcels can be opened carefully during the last 5 minutes of baking. The steam is hot, so they should be opened away from the face. This step gives the top of the baked whole herring a deeper color while keeping the onions juicy.
The herring is served hot, directly in the parchment or transferred to plates with the soft onions, carrot and pan juices spooned over it. Fresh lemon wedges and cherry tomatoes make the dish brighter and more balanced.
Leftovers can be cooled, covered and refrigerated for up to 2 days; they are best reheated gently in a low oven for 8 to 10 minutes.
For more tempting fish dishes, try the aromatic butterflied baked fish with lemon and herbs and the golden quick pan-fried trout with butter for a fresh dinner idea.














